Every time Celtic step onto the pitch in the Scottish Premiership this season, controversy over refereeing decisions seems to follow.
Their latest win over Kilmarnock was no exception. While the performance didn’t exactly meet the high standards of the fans or manager Brendan Rodgers, the crucial three points were secured, bringing some relief back to Glasgow.
However, the aftermath saw Kilmarnock boss Derek McInnes voicing his frustrations.
While McInnes wasn’t shy about lamenting his side’s stats, it was his disagreement with Sky Sports pundit Kris Boyd over a contentious tackle by Celtic’s Reo Hatate that grabbed attention.
Boyd, the former Rangers striker, was adamant: “That’s a red card all day long.” McInnes, though, saw it differently, suggesting Boyd had overplayed the severity of the challenge.
In search of clarity, Sky Sports’ Ref Watch stepped in. Former Premier League referee Dermot Gallagher reviewed the incident and backed the on-field decision.
“I think it looks worse than it is,” said Gallagher. “It’s a plastic pitch, so he’s sliding along it.
“He starts low, he does catch him but I don’t think he generates intensity, and he does pull out as well.
“And by pulling out, that’s why his foot comes up. I think the referee has got the best view.
“It’s not nice but it’s a yellow card for me.”
Gallagher’s take provided some relief for Celtic fans, as the yellow card issued by referee Nick Walsh was deemed appropriate, a view also supported by VAR.
VAR and Celtic
For Celtic, VAR controversies have become a recurring theme. Brendan Rodgers’ side has frequently found itself at the centre of debate as they defend their Premiership title.
Against Motherwell, for instance, Celtic were denied what appeared to be a clear penalty after Daizen Maeda was fouled in the box at Fir Park. Meanwhile, Gallagher dismissed claims that Aberdeen’s disallowed goal against Celtic was harsh, again siding with VAR.
Though VAR decisions have frustrated fans, this time the technology worked in Celtic’s favour, rightly sparing Hatate from a red card.