John Souttar has shown an admirable response for Rangers since their defeat in the Old Firm derby and merits consideration for a spot in the Scottish Premiership best XI, according to Scott Allan.
The Kelty Hearts player voiced his opinion during a discussion on PLZ Soccer on 9 October, debating who would make the ideal line-up since the beginning of the season.
He suggested that Souttar, the Scottish centre-back, should be the top choice from Rangers, noting that Celtic’s Kasper Schmeichel edges out Jack Butland in terms of form.
Peter Martin, who hosted the debate, had speculated that Butland might be the only realistic candidate from Rangers given the “alarming” state of the squad at Ibrox.
But Allan saw things differently, offering a more positive take on Souttar’s recent performances.
Allan remarked (45m 50s): “Based on since the Celtic-Rangers game I think Souttar arguably could be in there for me. I think he’s responded really well to that game and Rangers have obviously had on the back of it clean sheets, so maybe Souttar in there if any.”
Peter Martin was quick to clarify: “In place of Carter-Vickers?” To which Allan replied, “Well, he’s injured isn’t he.”
Tam McManus also backed the inclusion of Souttar, weighing in with his view: “I’m not sure about Carter-Vickers,” which further fuelled the debate.
Martin then expressed concern about Rangers’ overall contribution to a best XI, stating: “Only Rangers player which is quite alarming.”
The notion of dropping Jack Butland and slotting John Souttar in ahead of Cameron Carter-Vickers for Rangers may raise eyebrows, but it’s indicative of where things currently stand for the club.
Despite their storied history, Philippe Clement’s side languish in third place, trailing Celtic and Aberdeen by five points, and failing to make a significant mark early in the campaign.
Given the context, it’s not entirely shocking that this evolving Rangers squad doesn’t offer many clear candidates for a league best XI.
Souttar’s performances have been patchy, but his form has improved considerably after a rocky, injury-hit start to life in Glasgow following his switch from Hearts three summers ago.
The 28-year-old is reportedly on the verge of signing a new contract [Daily Record, 1 October], which seems more a precautionary measure to prevent another high-profile free transfer rather than a direct reward for his form.
Yet, in a backline fraught with uncertainty—Ben Davies hasn’t impressed, Leon Balogun is nearing the twilight of his career at 36, and Robin Propper hasn’t quite filled the shoes of Connor Goldson—Souttar has emerged as the best option by necessity as much as design.
Meanwhile, James Tavernier, who has long been Rangers’ talisman, usually able to make a case for inclusion in such best XI debates, has seen a significant drop in form.
His performances have tailed off dramatically, and he now faces a genuine battle to retain his place in the team, even with the backing of Clement.
There are a few bright spots in Rangers’ current line-up. Nedim Bajrami, for instance, has shown glimpses of promise and could force his way into the conversation if he maintains his recent good form.
However, unless Clement manages to close the gap on the leaders, Rangers may find themselves shut out of major accolades this season.