Celtic produced a frustrating performance on Sunday, just a week after their League Cup triumph over Rangers, as they played out a goalless draw at Dundee United.
Brendan Rodgers’ side dominated possession and spent much of the game in the final third, but a lack of sharpness in front of goal and poor decision-making saw them fail to break down a disciplined Dundee United defence.
Despite registering 17 shots, only three were on target, while their opponents managed two shots on goal, both of which tested Celtic goalkeeper Kasper Schmeichel.
Rodgers made several changes from the Hampden Park victory, with key players like Cameron Carter-Vickers, Alistair Johnston, and Nicolas Kuhn missing due to illness. This gave fringe players a chance to impress, but many failed to seize the opportunity.
Pat Bonner Critical of Luis Palma
One player who drew criticism was Luis Palma, who came on in the 60th minute but failed to make a significant impact.
Celtic legend Pat Bonner was unimpressed with the 24-year-old’s performance, describing him as too predictable and questioning his suitability for the starting XI.
Speaking on BBC Radio Scotland, Bonner said:
“I have always wondered why Palma can’t play on the right-hand side, because he can’t play with his left foot. He always comes on the inside. When Maeda was still on the pitch, at that point, he could still play on the left and the right-hand side.
“I have said so many times when I watch him play. You have got to be able to go on the outside and the inside. You can’t keep coming in on the inside all the time. You come on the pitch, then you have to make a real impact. I know he had a shot, but that’s all I have seen of him so far. That’s why he’s not in the team, I am afraid.”
Palma’s Disappointing Stats
Palma’s performance against Dundee United highlighted his lack of rhythm, which can partly be attributed to his limited minutes this season—just 143 in total. However, his inability to capitalize on his opportunity was clear.
WhoScored rated his 30-minute cameo at 6.19, the lowest among Celtic players. Palma recorded four unsuccessful touches—more than anyone else on the pitch. His final numbers revealed a lack of influence:
Palma’s struggles highlight the need for squad players to step up when given the chance, especially at a club of Celtic’s stature. With competition for places fierce, performances like this may explain why he remains on the fringes of Rodgers’ plans.
